Perfume chemist Josh Stevens has spent years making a life for himself in New York City and climbing up the corporate ladder of Kiss and Makeup, a global cosmetics company. Although his cousin, Emma, whips up soul-mate predictions with their late grandmother's pink enchanted mixing spoon each Monday during Batter Up night, he'd rather experiment with vanilla perfume oil than vanilla extract any day. Buttermilk Falls and magic are not for him. Little did he know that a run in last summer with the one woman from his hometown he's tried all these years to forget would turn his bachelor life upside down and bring him back for good. Caitlin Reynolds just needs a second chance. Sure, she's done some questionable things in the past, but as the new owner of the Majestic Theater, she is determined to turn her life around, contribute to the town's livelihood, and prove to all of Buttermilk Falls that she's more than the spoiled rich girl who got pregnant. While Josh and Caitlin adjust to their new normal, they begin to realize just how strong their feelings are for one another. But are they destined for each other? A ghost who likes to roam the Majestic Theater in a wedding dress and watch classic movies might be able to answer that.